Tucked away in the pristine waters of Lake George, often called the “Queen of American Lakes,” sits a one-of-a-kind, seven-bedroom estate that blends history, architecture, and natural beauty. For the first time in over 60 years, this storied island residence—known as 14 Mile Island—is up for sale, listed at $10.8 million.
Table of Contents
Legacy
The history of 14 Mile Island is as rich as its views. The name dates back to the 18th century, when British soldiers mistakenly believed they were 14 miles from the southern end of the lake, though they were actually 11 miles away. In 1857, the state of New York sold the island to William Smith, who also purchased five other nearby islands.
Since then, 14 Mile Island has lived many lives: a hotel, a steamship stop, and since 1905, a private summer estate. It was William Beardsley, a later owner, who commissioned architect John W. Ingle to design the summer home that still stands today.
Design
What makes this property so special isn’t just the location—it’s the architectural soul built into it. Ingle, a New York City architect, camped on the island to study the landscape before finalizing his plans. His attention to detail shows in features like clerestory windows in the great room, which were perfectly positioned to bring in light, fresh air, and even moonlight.
One of the standout features is a 3,000-square-foot curved porch, supported by 17 hand-crafted pillars made from local Shelving Rock stone. The porch, set slightly off from the main house, was placed with precision to capture the best sunlight.
The home also boasts post-and-beam craftsmanship and a stunning two-story stone fireplace in the great room—details that have aged beautifully over more than a century.
Property
Beyond the main house, the estate includes a beautifully restored boathouse that features a two-bedroom guest suite. This structure earned the 2019 Adirondack Architectural Heritage Award, a nod to the extraordinary care and attention that current owners, the Finley family, have given the entire estate since purchasing it in 1960.
With over 2,600 feet of shoreline, the island offers an unprecedented amount of privacy. Most lake homes, according to listing agent Crystal Staepal, sit on just 100 to 300 feet of waterfront. This property’s shoreline, along with its private lagoon and gazebo, sets it in a league of its own.
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Bedrooms | 7 |
| Shoreline | 2,600+ feet |
| Lot Size | 3+ acres |
| Porch | 3,000 sq. ft. curved, stone-supported |
| Boathouse | Includes 2-bedroom guest quarters |
| Architecture Award | Adirondack Heritage Award (2019) |
| Seaplane Access | FAA-registered seaplane base |
Access
You’d think a property this private would be remote—but that’s not the case. Just minutes by boat from Bolton Landing, the estate is close to chic boutiques, dining options, and the famed Sagamore Resort. It’s also a short trip from Saratoga Springs, Lake Placid, Vermont, and even Canada.
And for those with private aircraft, the island includes an FAA-registered seaplane base, allowing for water landings and tethering—an ultra-rare feature even among the most luxurious island homes.
Rarity
There are 186 islands on Lake George, and only a small number are privately owned. Of those, only a handful ever hit the market. That makes this listing truly rare—not just in price or size, but in legacy.
“This is the kind of property you never want to leave,” says Staepal. “It’s not just a home; it’s a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a piece of one of America’s most beautiful lakes.”
She’s not exaggerating. In a world of lookalike luxury homes, 14 Mile Island stands alone—rich in history, architecture, and the kind of serenity that only a private island can provide.
FAQs
Where is 14 Mile Island located?
It’s on Lake George near Bolton Landing, NY.
How much shoreline does the island have?
The estate features over 2,600 feet of shoreline.
Can you land a plane on the island?
Yes, it has a registered seaplane base.
How many bedrooms are in the estate?
The main house includes seven bedrooms.
Who currently owns the island?
The Finley family, who bought it in 1960, are the current owners.
